灯下 登录
数学 / 几何原本 / Proposition VIII.17

第8卷命题 17 · 立方数不测则边不测

If a cube number do not measure a cube number, neither will the side measure the side; and, if the side do not measure the side, neither will the cube measure the cube.

若一个立方数不能量度另一个立方数,则其边也不能量度另一边;反之,若边不能量度另一边,则立方数也不能量度另一立方数。

A A_r B B_r C C_r D D_r
fig-1

本页以“立方数不测则边不测”整体图解辅助阅读;点、线、角、圆索引已按命题文字和证明步骤校订,可与证明和问答联动。

线

正文图形由校订坐标生成;点、线、角、圆可与证明和问答联动。

分步证明Step-by-step proof
1 / 4
  1. For let the cube number A not measure the cube number B, and let C be the side of A, and D of B; I say that C will not measure D. For if C measures D, A will also measure B.

    设立方数A不能量度立方数B,且C是A的边,D是B的边。

  2. [VIII. 15] But A does not measure B; therefore neither does C measure D.

    若C量度D,则根据VIII.15,A也量度B,与假设矛盾,故C不能量度D。

  3. Again, let C not measure D; I say that neither will A measure B.

    反之,设C不能量度D。

  4. For, if A measures B, C will also measure D.

    若A量度B,则根据VIII.15,C也量度D,与假设矛盾,故A不能量度B。